Greed/Karma/Good deeds

2 years, 9 months ago

Recently I’ve been reading a lot into Buddhist philosophies and the idea of Karma. I think it can be agreed on that in a simple enough sense karma is just: “do good, good comes to you” and “do bad, bad comes to you.” Now this makes complete sense to me from personal experience and other reading i’ve done on karma. But one thing that I was left wondering about was this:

If somebody believes strongly in karma and this belief has given them strong motivations to do good and be good to others, then that’s good, right?

Well what if this same person begins to develop a kind of greed that goes hand in hand with karma. This person could begin to think “Oh, if I do good then good comes to me. I will always do good to manifest all of these positive effects on my life and then I will always be happy.” So they begin to jump on every opportunity they find to do good. And if you apply this to the basic ideology of karma, good things will come to him right? Well to me this seems shallow. This just sounds no different to me than that one kid who every year on halloween takes the entire bowl of candy that the family who couldn’t be home to hand it out left out on their porch. This person begins to only do good so that he can ensure a good/positive future for himself and quite frankly he could care less about the results of these “good deeds.”

Personally I think this comes down to intention, and that intention comes hand in hand with karma. With good intention comes positive things, but with a selfish intention you’re doing no better than you were before even if you’re attempting to drown yourself in good karma.

April 22, 2012 at 10:56 am

You must sign in or join to reply!

1
Profile photo of Mikey W Mikey W (@mikeyw829) 2 years, 9 months ago ago

I think intention is all that matters as well. Doesn’t matter what the action looks like on the surface, it’s the intention underneath that counts. For instance, I don’t think a person can really say that ALL war is bad, that ALL confrontation is bad, or that ALL non-violence is good, etc. You can’t just look at the surface of it. That also implies that in reality no physical action can really be judged as good or bad except by the person doing the action. Problem is a lot of the time we aren’t really conscious of the real reasons as to why we do certain things.

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of Rehum P Rehum P (@wesker53r86) 2 years, 9 months ago ago

sometimes doing the right thing isn’t always a good idea. I’ve been an asshole in many points in my life and I’m aware of it, even when i’m acting like an asshole. if you’ve ever watched fight club, then there’s suddenly a thin line between good and preserving good. You see there are times where we have to do bad things to good people to make others realize the gravity of an issue but then again, it’s hard to define a ‘good’ person to people with different ideas.

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of Mikey W Mikey W (@mikeyw829) 2 years, 9 months ago ago

@wesker53r86, what is “the right thing” though? Sometimes acting like an asshole is the right thing. Seemingly positive actions are not always the right thing to do (like non-violence, non-confrontation, turning the other cheek, etc). If you do something ‘bad’ to a ‘good’ person to make them realize something bigger and better, then aren’t you actually doing ‘good’? I would say you are. Again, it comes down to intention.

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of Shredder Shredder (@shredder) 2 years, 9 months ago ago

@Alex, I’m not sure you’re looking at the big picture of the ‘good deeds’ you mention. If they are truly good, it benefits someone altruistically(other than self) and it does not matter the self gets positive results back. Of course people want positive results, though, and there’s nothing wrong with wanting to help people out of reciprocity. Karma is much less important than doing good deeds. I can’t know just because I do a good deed I will benefit down the line; however, I can receive satisfaction and possibly returned favors from helping others.

Taking a whole bowl of candy is not a good example as it is not a good deed done with future benefit in mind as you were talking about. There’s nothing greedy about wanting positive things for yourself, and as long as you genuinely want to help others then there is harmony.

**Example: Friend needs help with labor. You offer to help because you don’t want to see your friend stressed. Friend offers you money for your effort and you gladly accept(or decline). No greed, just a good deed. Even if you have the thought of reward in mind and it is the only reason you decide to help, you are still helping so it is not selfish. I advise learning to take joy in the deeds themselves since tangible rewards aren’t everything.

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of Mikey W Mikey W (@mikeyw829) 2 years, 9 months ago ago

@Shredder, so doing a ‘good deed,’ even if you feel totally empty inside while you’re doing it, is still a ‘good deed’? What if there’s no appreciation for the deed on the other end, either? Then it couldn’t be a good deed, it just looks that way. Intention behind the actions is really important in my opinion.

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of Shredder Shredder (@shredder) 2 years, 9 months ago ago

@Mikey W, of course intention is important; if you don’t intend to do a good deed then chances are a good deed will not be done. I think it is pretty clear whether an action helps another person or not, even if they don’t appreciate it. I don’t know much about feeling empty inside while doing good deeds, I need an example of this. I imagine that no, it is not a good deed, and certainly not what I was talking about. I mean truly having a desire to bring goodness into the lives of others, and maybe knowing goodness might come into yours as a result.

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of Rehum P Rehum P (@wesker53r86) 2 years, 9 months ago ago

@Mikey W, exactly… the line between the two becomes much thinner and thinner when you see both sides of the argument

[Hidden]
Reply to this topic

More Posts Like This

1

Streamlet of consciousness

blitzed in the early coursing midnight and palsied out, neatly, on the frenetic curb of a five blunt rotation. spliced into reality’s sharp edge. A gyrating universe crank silhouetted askance stilted time tableaus...

1

My Dream Life Infringes on My Real Life!

Hi all! For just a little background info, I have been dreaming my other life for 24 years now. I fall off to sleep and enter into my next life not skipping a beat. I will give you my dream resume: Spring of 1991-Fall of...

4

Your biggest questions in life?

I have many questions I would love to be answered, but it occured to me there are probably tonnes more great questions I haven’t even thought of. What are some of the questions you would like to know the most, or...

6

Any Trip Stories?

I just wanted to make a hot discussion with a lot of replies and i also like sharing and listening to trip stories so if you have one feel free to share it and it might also help people who hasn’t tripped but are...

2

acid room

Hey guys this is reiko the dragon and I wanted to know about your experiences with acid and I also wanted to know if anything tops acid or comes close to the experience

1

I have a guy problem – I really don't like guys.

Hi. I need advice…. I am having a really hard time *liking* guys. I feel like if I make out with a guy more than once if we are drunk or just at a party I tend to have feelings for them, or grow feelings for them,...

1

Paying for college is for the experience not the classes.

Hey everyone. So my name is Chris and I actually found this website yesterday. I have been on it non-stop today in between my crazy college schedule. I have found a lot of people who are posting about how bad college is!...

1

Looking for friends ?

I’m Indian, 17, I read a lot, I’m pretty normal I think. Smoke weed sometimes, just looking for cool people to talk to and share worries with. I’m a good listener and have some free time on my hands, so...

18

Suggestions for a site-wide HE 30 day challenge?

**I’ve created a poll for the different types of challenges here: http://tally.tl/BEnr2** —- Starting in February, we’re going to have monthly 30-day challenges! We had a very successful challenge years...

1

Street Art

Hey ya’ll. I’ve just gotten started cutting stencils and playing around with shading and blending colors. I’m posting this just to reach out to those of you who are interested in art in general to...

1

HighExistence Skype Group

If I were to create some sort of group, most likely on Skype but could be anywhere, would you guys participate in it? It would just be a nice place for advice, intellectual discussions, the human mind, literally anything...

1

Questioning the Color Spectrum

My friends and i were arguing about the color spectrum tonight. The debate was whether or not an alternate color spectrum’s exists aside from the white-to-black and rainbow color spectrum’s. Perhaps there is...

22

What single change would have the MOST positive impact on the world?

Could be societal, political, economical, etc. In other words, if we could only change ONE thing about the world to better our lives, what should it be?

2

Choices 'n' Dilemmas

I am currently in my second year of college, with 5 months to go till i finish. I left secondary school with really good grades and finished the first year of college with once again really good grades. That was when I...

2

Meditation Report

I was on a cross country drive with 3 other friends in a small refurbished school bus in which we removed all but 2 seats and laid a bunch of mattresses down. We were on our way from New Jersey to Mississippi to pick up...