Jesus question

2 years, 1 month ago

My friend was trying to explain how in the Christian religion they believe Jesus “Died for our sins.” Now I don’t understand this, usually when someone dies FOR something they’re dying for something good. For example; Soldiers die to protect certain rights, freedom and people. So to me it would make more sense if Jesus dyed FOR the goodness of all. Am i making sense? Can someone explain this to me.

December 9, 2012 at 10:19 pm

You must sign in or join to reply!

1
Profile photo of Iflookscouldreallykill Iflookscouldreallykill (@iflookscouldkill) 2 years, 1 month ago ago

@iambrian, Trying to make sense of this is a lost cause. The term ‘died for our sins’ im pretty sure is a misinterpretation of the original texts. But it sounds dramatic enough right? Curious that Christians seem to care more about the death of Jesus than all the beautiful lessons of love he taught while living.

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of Zykanthos Zykanthos M (@chodebalm) 2 years, 1 month ago ago

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of Alex Alex (@staylucky) 2 years, 1 month ago ago

@iambrian, Soldiers die to protect certain rights? That’s news to me..

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of Starry Eyed BLiND. Starry Eyed BLiND. (@cristinelizabeth) 2 years, 1 month ago ago

Wasn’t the devil like bff’s with Jesus at one point and then he was banished? Well what if during that time they were like, okay lets make these people feel like they sin against the greater good and threaten them of the eternal damned or utopia and see how they each take this information in their human lives with such opportunities to indulge in sins and being a good person.
I don’t know my religious stance, I feel spiritual though. But dying for our sins kind of sounds like we are the victims of some huge sin that we have already made when we are born?
Another thing, Jesus was Jewish right, so why do people like feel negative about Jewish people, and why are they Christian not Jewish?

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of  Anonymous (@) 2 years, 1 month ago ago

@iambrian, Essentially, Jesus took one for the team/ bailed us out so we could learn how to live a good life.

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of Eric Eric M (@blankey) 2 years, 1 month ago ago

@iambrian, It’s all bullshit in my opinion, so don’t even worry about it! :) By the way, I grew up Catholic and spent Kindergarten through Senior year of High School studying the good ol’ dude Jesus, so I’m not just some dude.

Also, sins would require the idea of right and wrong. Your right can be my wrong and vise versa.

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of BriGuy BriGuy (@iambrian) 2 years, 1 month ago ago

I feel like Jesus was just a great guy who possibly was ‘awakened’, and just wanted people to love, and basically laid down some basic concepts so the average Joe could live a life of love. But of course human nature is to twist and exaggerate things. So now people worship and and believe in pearly gates or eternal fire afterlife and a whole bunch of other stuff that most likely isn’t true IMO. I should probably read the bible and do some more research before I draw conclusions about the worlds most popular belief though…

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of Ray Butler Ray Butler M (@trek79) 2 years, 1 month ago ago

@iambrian, Look at the history of Judaism: Jewish would make an animal sacrifice, the sin of the family is put into the animal then the animal is destroyed. This clenses the family of their sin for a time. Sin is inherited from Adam and Eve, it is what they chose and it is what drives us away from a relationship with God.
To place your sin on an animal then destroy it was a way to come back toward God, not completely but enough to forge some kind of relationship. But an animal is an imperfect creature, so are human beings, but in Christian belief Jesus was perfect, the perfect sacrifice. Being an absolute, this perfect sacrifice can cover the sin of all mankind for all time.
The ransom sacrifice of the perfect vessel means humans can come to a more fulfilled relationship with God then ever before, but the cost is repentance, turning away from sin, which means although you cannot help to sin you never do it with intent and you actively try to avoid it where you can.
Originally, even if you did this, you would gradually degrade into a state unfit for a relationship with God, but now that degradation is automatically reversed simply by repentance, turning away, avoiding the intent of sin and avoiding sin where it is possible to do so.

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of Mayhaffs Mayhaffs (@newworldscholar) 2 years, 1 month ago ago

Here is a concept from “The Power of Now.” It goes something like: Jesus was a man who died and became Christ. This means that Jesus defeated all sense of his ego (which is sin) and become one with Christ (which is God or Infinity or the Interconnectedness or the Supreme Perception).

The story of Jesus is used to exemplify the process of defeating the ego, becoming a non-sinner, and transcending into the presence of God.

God is defined as a limitless being. Therefore god is equal to infinity and equal to one. From there we see than infinity is inherent in everything. We are all one!

The act of sinning is when you have more faith in your own self of self than your faith in God and the essence in which we all share. (In order to violate any of the ten commandments, you must prioritize your identity before the essence that is constructed in all things).

If you kill your ego completely and have no desires or identity then you can not die, because the only thing left is the essence that is ubiquitous in atom in the universe.

When Adam of the garden of Eden became a sinner for taking the apple from the forbidden tree. He did not become a sinner because he took the apple. He became a sinner because he put his faith in his ego and created the desire to eat the apple. Adam put more faith in his ego than his faith in God.

Every religion has great knowledge to offer. It all depends on how you look at it. :)

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of Alex Alex (@staylucky) 2 years, 1 month ago ago

@newworldscholar, There are certain flaws to this approach but quite frankly that’s the best case scenario of the explanation of the bible I’ve heard so kudos!

Pity mankind can’t see it that way in our modern era.

But everything is ego now. Facebook vague status updates to initiate concern, post your food on Instagram, Check-in to bars and clubs that are supposedly such fun that you found the time to tear yourself away from the enjoyment to let everyone else know. Me, me, me. Too many morons have been given a platform to voice themselves and feel important and yes even as I type this I realise I am rambling so I will shut up… now.

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of Ray Butler Ray Butler M (@trek79) 2 years, 1 month ago ago

The only real point in Christianity and the Bible is not a whole mumbo jumbo about ego, it is just about intent. You will do the wrong thing often, but what is your intent? Simple.
There are a hell of a lot of ways to interpret stories in the Bible: I think the story of Adam and Eve is about concepts, the fruit of the tree of the knowledge of good and bad, it is eaten. This means the abilities of concept, design of our own values, taking concept in so that it becomes our identity. Concepts have their place as a tool to improve things but Adam and Eve made it more than what it is supposed to be, our identity, that it is all we really are, but it is not.
As a result we have all the sins because concept is misused and is at the root of all things injurious. However if concept is used correctly, it becomes the tree of life.
But as I said, that is a bunch of hoohah, it is all and only about our intent, we have no choice but to sin but we do have power over our intent, to be of malice or to apply it appropriately.

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of R.Steve Hardy R.Steve Hardy (@rstevehardy) 2 years, 1 month ago ago

All your opinions are just that opinions,and most sound like BS to me.

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of Jim Jim (@7dabs) 2 years, 1 month ago ago

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of Ray Butler Ray Butler M (@trek79) 2 years, 1 month ago ago

@rstevehardy, My first comment is not an opinion, that is exactly what “Jesus died for our sins” means, or is supposed to. Christians don’t do animal sacrifices because of that. But then they invented a whole bunch of crap about confession, which is completely irrelevant and only for people who don’t even want to attempt self-control.
My second comment, yes opinion, but BS? Yes in the sense that you don’t need to know it.

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of Adeel Adeel (@nooneknows) 2 years, 1 month ago ago

This is where each one of you is wrong. Jesus did not die on the cross. He was saved and went on to live for a long time to the age of 120 and then Died a natural death in Kashmir.

http://tombofjesus.com/

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jesus_in_Ahmadiyya_Islam

[Hidden]
2
Profile photo of Matthew Matthew (@ojai) 2 years, 1 month ago ago

@nooneknows, Fucking hipsters.

Too cool to accept the death of JC as a crucifixion huh

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of Ray Butler Ray Butler M (@trek79) 2 years, 1 month ago ago

@blankey, Sin is not right or wrong, it is the misuse of our concepts, unavoidable in a being that is not all knowing. If you have no connotation to it, it still cannot be denied that certain things are beneficial, as they make things easier or pain is avoided, this is the best use of concepts and no matter what we do we can never completely avoid accidental counter-productivity.
So it comes down to intent, if you intend harm or not. This does not mean that if you did not intend you are not accountable, but rather the opposite, people who make mistakes unintentionally, these people always take responsibility, it is the people who do intend harm that deny it was their fault.

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of ELI var namnet ELI var namnet (@manimal) 2 years, 1 month ago ago

You can’t make sense of religion.

Religion is retarded and doesn’t make sense at all.

It’s just one huge misconception.

Ignore it.

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of Adeel Adeel (@nooneknows) 2 years, 1 month ago ago

Also, in Islam it is clearly told that no one is responsible for sins of another person. This was just used as an excuse and is now a belief. To believe in religion or not is a whole diff. Topic.
Im not trying to preach anything here, just that all of you should know many people believe Jesus did not die at the cruxifixion, research about it and then choose your side.

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of Ray Butler Ray Butler M (@trek79) 2 years, 1 month ago ago

Wow, I don’t assign to religion, I don’t think it is needed. The only value I see is for introspection, that you can see the logic and benefit in interacting with people in the most appropriate way, whatever that may mean to you. But so many people are so jaded by religion, hostile reactions to what you claim is so pointless, if you really believe religion is so irrelevant then you could objectively discuss it rather than out bursting in a bias view.
The fact is religion is NOT irrelevant because so many people assign to one incarnation or another and they are passionate about it, and most of the rest of people so passionately respond against it. It seems it is relevant to all, as I see it.

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of Zack Armstrong Zack Armstrong (@lifetimeclimber) 2 years, 1 month ago ago

@manimal, Just because you don’t believe in a particular religion does not mean it is retarded. I think we can all relate to the main theme throughout most religions which is to become a better person. If you actually read the bible it is one continuous story which has hundreds if not thousands of valuable lessons for life. Sure, it has some contradictions in it but that doesn’t take away the value of the knowledge that is there. It’s kind of annoying how people dismiss religion as useless bullshit because of a few contradictions. I’m not saying you should become a christian, I’m just saying you shouldn’t dismiss the value of christianity even if it isn’t true.

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of Kip Goeing Kip Goeing (@kipgoeing) 2 years, 1 month ago ago

If Jesus died for our sins, why did he supposedly rise from death? How are the sins getting paid if he’s alive?

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of Tony Tony (@antlob) 2 years, 1 month ago ago

@lifetimeclimber, The bible also has hundreds of stupid ass rules.

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of kempsishere kempsishere (@kempsishere) 2 years, 1 month ago ago

The way I was taught as a child, as well as my adult understanding today, lead me to this. Eve was the first human to commit sin by eating the forbidden fruit. God cast Adam and Eve out of the garden of Eden, and humankind was forced to live harsh lives and struggle with temptation. Those who were victorious, for the most part, would be admitted to heaven, those who were not, to hell (with a few in the gray area that wait in purgatory). Jesus, as Christians believe, was the Messiah, whose purpose in life was to give his own life so that we may be free from sin. In the three days between Jesus’ death and resurrection, he guided all the souls in hell up to heaven, opening the gates to all people and, therefore, saving us from our sins.

[Hidden]
1

@iambrian, I think it’s not so much the dying as it was his suffering. He supposedly suffered/died to earn God’s forgiveness on behalf of all those who follow him and accept him as their savior.

I think It’s all based on the inherent belief that we’re all born into sin/going to hell (as in “original sin”…Adam & Eve bullshit) and the only way to absolve yourself of this sin is to accept Christ as your lord & savior, worshipping him as the son of God, and following his teachings…or some shit like that.

I DON’T KNOW. I’m not a Christian or Catholic of any form. This is what my understanding of it is based on what religious people have told me. I’m likely just talking out my ass.

[Hidden]
Reply to this topic

More Posts Like This

14

Suggestions for a site-wide HE 30 day challenge?

Starting in February, we’re going to have monthly 30-day challenges! We had a very successful challenge years back when the discussions were first added to HE. It’s time to revive them! Which challenge should...

22

What single change would have the MOST positive impact on the world?

Could be societal, political, economical, etc. In other words, if we could only change ONE thing about the world to better our lives, what should it be?

1

General Grammar, Logic, and Rhetoric. (The trivium)

Is there anyone here who are interested in these topics as a means of self development? The reason i am asking is that it would be interesting to make a group of people to cooperate in order to excel at these subjects....

1

Band Names

So my friend is obsessed with trying to find a name for his band, they just finished doing all their recordings, but still can’t settle on a title. Here’s how he describes their sound: A lighter style...

1

Embrace Your Surroundings

So a couple months ago I read this beautiful and amazing book titled Ishmael. A very special friend suggested I read it, and it completely changed my outlook on Western culture and our modern civilization. I recommend...

1

Yoga-Meditation music

Hello everyone, I need your help, The last month I find good music in HE. This is the link: http://www.highexistence.com/links/view/above-beyond-burning-man-2014/page/71/ I really love this song, but I’m horrible...

1

How to Suck at Life and Totally Waste Everyone's Time.

step 1:Argue with everyone Step2: Always argue Step3: Be an ass hole for fun Step4: Post videos and links to prove a point Step5: Do all of the above while on this website

3

Sleep paralysis , OBE, lucid dream

I just had my first sleep paralysis, obe, ld. it happened out of nowhere and on a sober mind. I wanted to achieve lucid dreaming for so long and it finally happened! Im super excited! Even tho the sleep paralysis wasnt...

1

Red Rover Red Rover is education over?

To begin I would like to forewarn you that this is not a rant about the current education system (which I believe most people here view as flawed), rather a niche topic not really discussed. People earn an education to...

4

Are you smart or dumb? What is intelligence?

What’s smart and what’s dumb? What’s the difference between them? Is your intelligence fixed or fluid? One guy does well in school, devotes his life to the academic system. Becomes a master in his field...

1

Not sure what to do next?

I am 21 years old and recently extremely depressed with my existence. I’m not sure where I am going, or why I have ended up where I am in life.. I’ve always had a close group of friends who mean the world to...

1

SHE = super high existence

Why is the abbreviation of this amazing website another hidden sign that we live in a patriarchal society. HE, clearly referring to the male gender. So, women can’t be conscious and think of a higher existence ? To...

8

Marijuana + Meditation = ?

A couple weeks ago I tried meditating after smoking some weed. We sat on these two blocks in the middle of an empty park staring at the sky and meditating. It was the most peaceful 20 minutes of my life. So anyone ever...

1

Spirituality becoming a commodity?

I have been really disappointed where the “festival scene” is going in Colorado. This weekend I took LSD and went to a “show” not knowing what to expect. The first thing I see is a baby on the...