Kill few to safe many

3 years, 1 month ago

In a couple of threats about murder the phrase ‘Kill one to safe many’ seems to be the most logical reasoning for murder. In our current world the total population is rising out of hand to the max of our planets carrying capacity. Ofcourse we don’t really know how many we can sustain. But in this theme I’ve got two questions for yall.

1. Let’s say we’ve reached our carrying capacity and we know it, it’s 6 billion. Should we kill 1 billion people to safe the other 6? or would we just let it all happen and see who die and survive? (concluding in at least WAY more deaths than 1 billion, and way more damage).

2. Since there are so many people, is it actually worth it to let one familiar person live at the cost of 10 (or whatever) unknown people. There are so many anyway?!

Curious what you guys think of this :)

March 1, 2012 at 10:50 am

You must sign in or join to reply!

1
Profile photo of Jesse G. S. Jesse G. S. (@ehtrettahdammadhatterthe) 3 years, 1 month ago ago

there was something i read in my biology class about putting bacteria in a vacuum or something and giving it food. the bacteria grew and grew and grew and doubled each time and then, when the resources were all gone, it just died like that. i don’t think people would be okay with it. i’m not. and there are plenty of places to go, under water, underground, in space. hopefully by the time we reach capacity we will have some ideas on what to do about it. but i’ve heard a conspiracy theory that the new world order is gonna blow up most of the worlds population except for a few million or a couple billion, i don’t remember how much.

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of  Anonymous (@) 3 years, 1 month ago ago

The planet can probably sustain 3-4times the current population.

Culling the population and letting it fester for another 50 years, while people fuck and repopulate it without changing the problem means we’ll have to kill 2billion by the year 2050, and 3 billion by the year 2200.

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of Jesse G. S. Jesse G. S. (@ehtrettahdammadhatterthe) 3 years, 1 month ago ago

well my point about the bacteria, or atleast the books point was that once the population starts doubling, it starts doubling faster and faster. i think the population doubled in a couple centuries? i’ll look it up real quick.

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of Jesse G. S. Jesse G. S. (@ehtrettahdammadhatterthe) 3 years, 1 month ago ago

in the early 70’s. so that means the earths population has doubled in the past 40 years. imagine in twenty years well have 14 billion people on this planet lol

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of ejaz r. chaudhri ejaz r. chaudhri (@ajax) 3 years, 1 month ago ago

population explosion is a real threat in societies which do not encourage population planning. the planet space is limited and population is bursting at the seems, this is evident in china, India, Bangladesh, Pakistan etc.
the commuter trains , roads, shopping areas in London, India, New York , chick ago are full of people. even if you want to , you cant kill people in big numbers, and who on earth is going to do this, we have to learn to live with this. the future wars will be on water, gas, fuel, space
literate societies with mature approach may handle our problems other wise there will be wars with missiles flying all over us

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of Randall Randall (@randall) 3 years, 1 month ago ago

Well I’m trying to avoid the discussion about how much we can sustain, I hear a lot of that in my school studies and it’s simply unknown. Population can increase to about 10 billion in 2050, but there are also scientific books about theories that the population is about to decrease (higher developed countries actually decline, more countries are getting developed –> slowly our rates are going down and eventually in some decades the population should decrease).

I’d like to hear the philosophical idea, IF we were sure we would (nearly) extinct if we keep up this amount of people, would you kill those 1 billion people, and how?!

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of Jesse G. S. Jesse G. S. (@ehtrettahdammadhatterthe) 3 years, 1 month ago ago

it would have to be totally humane(like a slow acting delicious tasting euphoric bringing) gas, and they would probably decided to die themselves, for the better of mankind.

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of  Anonymous (@) 3 years, 1 month ago ago

Give them HIV and call it a vaccine. I don’t see how that’s philosophical though.

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of Jesse G. S. Jesse G. S. (@ehtrettahdammadhatterthe) 3 years, 1 month ago ago

yeah, we’d probably reach a point where we just couldn’t give people the resources they needed and people who were already dieing would be the first to go.

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of Randall Randall (@randall) 3 years, 1 month ago ago

Well.. Meh.. im not looking for ways of killing 1 billion people.
But like, should murdering be randomly all around the world, or focussed at one continent? Or would you just decide to let them all live and see what happens? Even if science would say that it’s going to be a total catastrophy

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of  Anonymous (@) 3 years, 1 month ago ago

Killing 1 billion or killing 6 billion is irrelevant if the same problem is going to arise within the next 50 years. It’s a nonsensical question, 1 billion people means nothing when we’re growing faster than that per annum.

The most logical solution is to let them live and see what happens, since any other action is simply prolonging the inevitable.

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of Morgan Morgan (@m17lee) 3 years, 1 month ago ago

A very good reason to adopt instead of having kids.

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of Sasho Stoyanov Anonymous (@) 3 years, 1 month ago ago

Funny how you talk about killing other people like you’re not part of the population. “them” “let them live” Who are they ? What are you ?
I think the world is doing its best to kill the ones who destroy it.

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of Nick Nick (@nickc2007) 3 years, 1 month ago ago

Could all stop fighting and work together to see if we can populate another planet somewhere…but there’s no money in that

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of Alex Alex (@hollowinfinity) 3 years, 1 month ago ago

The only population issue we will have is due to countries not being able to pull dicks out of their asses. There is an entire world, if we worked together we’d be fine. The world population is probably about to start going down anyways. China’s laws have an impact on this whole thing, ya know.

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of vishnu vishnu (@vizznou) 3 years, 1 month ago ago

well, talk about coincidence, there is a (canadian i think) organisation named development perspectives and their FB share today is this. and the title reads:

Is murder ever OK? Does killing a few justify the saving of many? Check out Michael Sandel – The Moral side of Murder …..
but i support Sasho’s first comment here. who are they, who are we?

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of Jordan Lejuwaan Jordan Lejuwaan A (@jordan) 3 years, 1 month ago ago
[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of Johannes Davidsson Johannes Davidsson (@daokedao) 3 years, 1 month ago ago

Nature always sorts itself out. The planet is ok! There’s nothing wrong with it. It’s just reacting to whatever we put it through. We on the other hand are fucked my dear Heathens. I personally believe that the transformation process of our planets consciousness isn’t fast enough and we have to destroy ourselves before we can build something new. How we destroy ourselves I do not now. Overpopulation, war, disease or lack of resources. All could have been taken care of through transcending our current way of thinking and living.

But as it is now we are kinda fucked =P
We have a lot of alternate energy resources and methods of implementing them, but we as a race are not striding towards the actual implementation of those inventions.

So if we as a race don’t actively do something as of now, murdering billions or just as bad letting mother nature follow her course, we won’t transcend that way of thinking.

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of Chris Chris (@comicsanmc) 3 years, 1 month ago ago

The earth has a comfortable carrying capactiy of 2 billion. Meaning two billion people can live on earth with an American standard of living. 2050 predictions slate the populace at 8-10.5 billion.

I don’t think we need to worry about it though. With the use of antibiotics on animals were spurring the creation of microbes that are resistant to treatment. When were living much closer together and our antibiotics aren’t functioning like they used to, we’ll start dropping like flies.

Nature is the great equalizer.

[Hidden]
Reply to this topic
What can you accomplish in 30 days? Join our site-wide challenge. Challenge Yourself

More Posts Like This

2

Profile photo of smbiplob Nature is complicated

Nature is complicated. Its far more complicated than a meager human brain can fathom. I hope you all understand this. It is one thing to say “Things are not black and white.” But it is another to say...

12
3

Profile photo of emptyminded The KABALAH!

Since all the threads I have found on this subject are old, I felt the need to make a fresh one dedicated to this most awesome system of ‘Life’ study. Those who wonder what it is, please ask, and those who...

90
1

Profile photo of Mac B. The Intergration of Technology and Nature.

I am like many of you on here, always thinking. Just the other night while on a hit of LSD, i started a vision quest. I started thinking about the future of humanity and how we are starting to live in a time where many...

0
21

Profile photo of Gare [HE 30 Day Challenge] April 2015 – Project or Skill

Hello good people! This month’s challenge is going to be different from the others in two ways: The nature of this challenge will allow you to actually show your progress throughout the month, making it more useful...

79
45

Profile photo of epidemic HOW TO NOT GIVE A FUCK

This post is in deliberate contrast to my JUST CHOOSE LOVE post. I believe in both of these statements. I believe that most people you know couldn’t give a shit whether you are dead or alive & everyone is...

63
1

Profile photo of LVX H.A.A.R.P. ?

Does this look natural to you? If it is natural then it is still pretty awesome. If it was somehow created by man I think it is kind of scary to ponder what we are playing with. At the moment I have no opinion as to what...

10
5

Profile photo of lexicakes The secret of a beautiful life

Embrace pain with all of your might, seek it frantically with the same intensity with which you seek pleasure. When you find it, be excited about finding it because sooner or later you realize that the power of all pain...

3
1

Profile photo of LVX Nature of Suffering and it's Role in Awakening

Hello friends. So I just wanted to start a discussion on suffering from a spiritual perspective. I thought I would say a bit about what I think and then hear what you all have to say. In my opinion I feel that suffering...

5
10

Profile photo of HarmanDS Nomadic lifestyle/Indefinite traveling

Does anyone here have experience with either living nomadic for a period of time or travelling indefinitely? I suppose these could be considered synonymous. I’ve been wanting to do this for at least 8 years now but...

23
1

Profile photo of LVX Spirit Science

Hey all, I just made account on this interesting site and got my first question. :) So, few months ago, I was talking with my friend about psychoactive drugs how it helped him to better “feel” and understand...

1
1

Profile photo of MonkeyZazu Get Up Now

I could of gave up thenbut it wasn’t my whentime was ticking fastand I knew it wouldn’t lastI had to get up now. I would of gave up thenbut it wasn’t my whenthe sun was setting todayand I knew I...

2
2

Profile photo of Prin Love

Love can break you,  Love can kill you, but it can also create you

0
3

Profile photo of Kimberly Cheeks InRetrospect: Faith

Honestly, I don’t what this is about or where this is going. I just feel the need to reach out. I hope this reaches each and everyone of you in good spirits with smiles on your faces. I need you all to understand...

3
1

Profile photo of Kristian I'm not telling you goodbye Dave…

You have an inoperable brain tumor and have 6 months to live. This is the news my work colleague Dave got last month. Dave is a soft spoken man with a big heart, hard work ethic, thirst for a variety of beers and rocks...

0
1

Profile photo of NihilismEnlightenment Does Good and Evil Exist in mind of the Doer ?

“If there is no extant God and no extant gods, no good and no evil, no right and no wrong, no meaning and no purpose: if there are no values that are inherently valuable; no justice that is ultimately justifiable; no...

0