Naturally good vs naturally evil

2 years, 5 months ago

Known as the eternal question, humans have been trying since the beggining of time to gather sufficient arguments that will support either side.

Are people naturally good or naturally evil?

November 22, 2012 at 5:56 pm

You must sign in or join to reply!

1
Profile photo of Almeida Almeida (@xetado) 2 years, 5 months ago ago

Naturally evil, in my opinion. I think this is more of a defensive mechanism, because although living in a society is not perfect but better than living alone, our mind at first probably thinks that selfless attitudes aren’t very positive in the surviving perspective.

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of ELI var namnet ELI var namnet (@manimal) 2 years, 5 months ago ago

THERE IS NO SUCH THING AS GOOD OR EVIL. They’re made up concepts with no real meaning.

There is only action and consequence.
Believing in good and evil is just an excuse for judging people and being holier-than-thou.

It isn’t real.

Humans are humans. And we’re all fucking different.

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of marthamena95 marthamena95 (@marthamena95) 2 years, 5 months ago ago

@xetado, do you mean that we are born evil but as a Defensive mechanism against society? But doesnt this make us naturally good becuase that means we are born in a inperfect society, and we have a natursk impetus to make it right? Or defend ourselves from it?
@manimal, There is good and evil because we create our reality. From your point of view, you could argue nothing really exist, right? Also, are you saying that all situations are neutral; as if all was just “it” and we as humans and observers have no right to judge, even if it is positive, as in constructive criticism?

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of DerpWard DerpWard (@aloofcat) 2 years, 5 months ago ago

@manimal, i agree with you. this might just be me just out of philosophy class, but it is true that good-evil are man-made concepts. it’s like trying to say a bee is evil because it stings. it is only it’s nature, as it is ours to overthink stuff that perhaps should be left alone.

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of marthamena95 marthamena95 (@marthamena95) 2 years, 5 months ago ago

@aloofcat, I undstand now, thanks for the bee example. as simple as it may sound for you, it really helped me :)

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of Almeida Almeida (@xetado) 2 years, 5 months ago ago

@marthamena95, Everybody lived “alone” in the beginning, but some people overcame the idea of being selfish and started to develop tribes, groups, societies, whatever, seeing that it was better. An alone mind would think it’s better to be selfish in order to be more adaptive , but not a collective mind. Sorry if you didn’t understand, my English is not so good..

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of ELI var namnet ELI var namnet (@manimal) 2 years, 5 months ago ago

@marthamena95, I guess you could argue that nothing exists, but I don’t see how that makes sense at all.
I’m not saying you have no right to judge, judge all you want. But it won’t make a difference.

There is no good and evil. Just actions and reactions. Cause and effect.
X leads to Y.

Good and evil are just silly fairytale concepts. Their effects on the human mind can be very crippling, this is the norm.
To the vast vast majority of people, as in almost no exceptions, the definitions of good and evil are not even their own or based on something rational, just indoctrination. Social conditioning.
It only serves to keep people down.

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of MPHill MPHill (@everymorningbornfromtheashes) 2 years, 5 months ago ago

I think though good and evil is a man made concept yes, accepting that humans have the ability to be good and evil is more of a social examination on the individual. To strive for either doesn’t hinder ones intellectual growth, and furthering your morals. So if you choose to allow the concepts of good and evil to keep you down as manimal says it will. If you choose to
allow the concepts to perpetuate yourself in a positive self-evaluation, I don’t believe I see a problem.

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of MPHill MPHill (@everymorningbornfromtheashes) 2 years, 5 months ago ago

@everymorningbornfromtheashes, And I will add also, with everything discrepancy.

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of  Anonymous (@) 2 years, 5 months ago ago

The concept of good and evil is a question of morality. Humans are the only creatures on the Earth that possess a sense of ‘morality’. Therefore – if we didn’t exist, the concept of ‘Morality’ would have never existed. A mother shark will attempt to eat her children upon birth. If they attempt to escape and should ever meet she wouldn’t even acknowledge the nonsensical ‘moral code’ in which we humans follow. Just like other tools of mass control, ‘morality’ is a system that dictates how to live a ‘morally good’ or ‘morally bad’ life. We must instead acknowledge the fact that humans are inherently free from the concept of morality. We are flawed, yes. Everyone possesses a certain amount of ‘evil’ within them. Terms such as ‘Bad/Good’ is simply a matter of perspective. Yet at the same time we all possess a certain understanding that allows us to ‘LIVE (evil backwards), reverberating within our spiritual vibrations and urging us to generate Positivity/Love/Compassion in the world. Life is balance. Two wolves. Yin & Yang. Adam & Eve. The concept has always been laid before our eyes.

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of marthamena95 marthamena95 (@marthamena95) 2 years, 5 months ago ago

@xetado, I understand your point. However, dont you think that as abraham lincoln famous quote says, The dogmas of the quiet past are inadequate to the stormy present. The occasion is piled high with difficulty, and we must rise with the occasion. As our case is new, so we must think anew and act anew.. This means that presently, because we as humans evolved into societies and civilizations, we have evolved on the idea that we were, some time in our past, born naturally evil? Meaning it is different now? We have changed?

@manimal, I actually never thought it that way, that the concepts of good and evil were matters of indotrination or social conditiong. However, it does make a lot of sense. But, maybe its more than just social. Good vs evil depends, obviously on our morals and values. What morals and values we have, depends on infinite number of factors, so, depending on this, you may argue on either side, right?

Maybe these concepts only serve as tools when , in every situation, deciding how to act and choosing what to do. simple as that.

@everymorningbornfromtheashes, Yess exactlyy! i thunk the same way as you do.

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of James McCarthy James McCarthy (@surrealseasons) 2 years, 5 months ago ago

We are natural beings. Nature is amoral. Therefore, we are not naturally ‘good’ or ‘evil’ but are amoral beings at birth.

[Hidden]
Reply to this topic
What can you accomplish in 30 days? Join our site-wide challenge. Challenge Yourself

More Posts Like This

1

Profile photo of ELI var namnet The Downer of the Now

Here and now, the present moment, is a limited time fragment sandwiched between two eternities.One is the past. The other is the future. Some of you will say these eternities are illusions, that they don’t exist,...

0
2

Profile photo of Martijn Schirp Mute

Hello :) For those of you who don’t know I am Shea. I have the challenge of going mute for as long as possible. It’s been extremely hard with school and the fact that I got sick and couldn’t tell the...

1
24

Profile photo of Trina [HE 30 Day Challenge] April 2015 – Project or Skill

Hello good people! This month’s challenge is going to be different from the others in two ways: The nature of this challenge will allow you to actually show your progress throughout the month, making it more useful...

96
2

Profile photo of Viner Cent What is the "ego"?

So, I have been wondering. I have read many discussions and posts “how to defeat your ego” “my ego is holding me back” “my ego is fighting against me” and so on and so on. Basically,...

0
3

Profile photo of Try Me Playa Going Mute

Today I realized that I didn’t need to talk anymore. There wasn’t anything I really needed to say. So starting tomorrow my friend and I were having this discussion and I will be going mute tomorrow for 30...

6
4

Profile photo of Magus Shared account to save on Lumosity?

Hi, so I just got into Lumosity and it would be great to do long term. The only thing is that its expensive, about 70 dollars a year for one person. But they offer a family plan thats 120 dollars a year for five...

71
5

Profile photo of J Man Reputation Anxiety

I feel anxiety when someone builds my reputation up. If I have a really solid interaction where the person compliments me and I can tell thinks highly of me, I don’t want to ruin this newfound image I’ve...

2
26

Profile photo of ShinyBug What single change would have the MOST positive impact on the world?

Could be societal, political, economical, etc. In other words, if we could only change ONE thing about the world to better our lives, what should it be?

95
1

Profile photo of Viner Cent How do you know what to do in your life?

Hi guys, i’ve got some problem with life :P I don’t know what to do in my life: now i’m studying(computer engineering) but don’t know if i want to get a job as engineer. I have a lot of hobby and...

3
62

Profile photo of Lowry No Porn: No Masturbation: 30 Days

I’m signing up. I’ve been reading some articles on that YourBrainOnPorn site. I do it like twice a week. But I do it like 3 times in a row. So I guess thats 6 times a week. Shit. Folks, Tomorrow will be my...

911
5

Profile photo of Mikey W Blaming The System Is a Lazy Person's Way of Thinking

Raise your hand if you’ve ever blamed “the system” for why you can’t just travel the world, do whatever you want, go wherever you want, and live for free. *Raises hand* There was a point in my...

2
1

Profile photo of Hasenfus Ethics of intoxication

I’m doing an essay for my ethics class in which I have to write my personal overview of ethics, including my own “Summum bonum” (or greatest good). The only aspect of my personal life which I lack...

0
8

Profile photo of Sean Yardley Happiness..

It seems to me, that what we as a people desire most in this life is happiness. We are constantly without end seeking out that good feeling inside of us that keeps us as a species trucking forward. There is something...

5
1

Profile photo of SwanSongRebeL What Is The Universe Expanding Into?

Come on, admit it, you’ve had this question. “Since astronomers know that the Universe is expanding, what’s it expanding into? What’s outside of the Universe?” Ask any astronomer and you’ll get an...

2
1

Profile photo of Zane Spaying and Neutering?

Just curious to know your take on it. Do you feel it is necessary? For those opposed or for it I’d like to here the reasoning behind it. Thanks.

17