Punishment

2 years, 1 month ago

I had two interesting relative thoughts, if we are punished and we do not question our punishment does that make us weak? And does accepting punishment and submitting give us mental strength?

Like if I were to of committed a crime that was in my nature, and I didn’t question why I was locked up then I would be lying to myself.

Or if I did something that was an accident against my nature but didn’t hesitate to argue that it was an accident and took the punishment, does that make me mentally strong?

Seem to not know how to feel about these things, your opinions?

December 5, 2012 at 8:06 pm

You must sign in or join to reply!

1
Profile photo of highideals highideals (@highideals) 2 years, 1 month ago ago

well… I’m unsure about this.

Since right and wrong are societally constructed.. who is to say it goes in either direction?
I believe that one can determine right and wrong based on life experiences personally. Therefore what is right to one may be wrong to another. And, in this same sense if we each have our own definitions of right and wrong i would say that the rest depends on integrity. And by integrity i mean that if we can assess what is right and what is wrong in our own individual reality, we can then judge based on our experiences to determine a logical punishment.. However, i am unsure if you are referring to a “godly intangible punishment” or one that is societally produced such as “federal law” Because if you look at it in godly terms their would be an all powerful “Truth” with a capital T. and this truth would reflect exactly what is wrong and what is right and how you are punished for doing wrong (hell or something like that). However i believe that their is no all powerful “Truth” and that right and wrong varies from situation to situation depending on context and previous experiences. Therefore who is one imperfect human to tell another imperfect human that what they are doing is right or wrong? Since right and wrong dont exist.. they are just creations of society to keep us in line.

Hope this helps…

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of ELI var namnet ELI var namnet (@manimal) 2 years, 1 month ago ago

@everymorningbornfromtheashes,

Depends what aspect of your mind you’re talking about. And what kind of questioning.

Fighting back always strengthens your mindframe, but it can weaken other parts of your mind, especially awareness and sense of truth. Because to keep a strong mindframe often means you must close your mind and project. Especially when you’re fighting for untruth or uncertainties, that’s guaranteed to lock you down.

If you do not question when you’re punished for something you didn’t do wrong, then you are plain weak. If you submit, then you are plain weak. Submission does not strengthen the mind, it only weakens it.
Most of all, it stifles the spirit, drops your self esteem, puts you in a purely reactive state. You lose all your power, and the mind tries to protect itself, this inevitably leads to a buildup of bullshit.

Your mind is always weakened when you’re not questioning. The fact that a person does not question is a surefire indicator of a weak mind.
The free mind is always curious, always wants to know, always wants to get ahead.

A weak mind is never free. Not all strong minds are free either, but a weak mind can never be free.
A weak mind is afraid of freedom, and keeps building more bullshit to keep itself locked tight.

Here’s some questions. What IS your nature? What IS an accident, REALLY?
How are you so sure that there really are such things to blame? How do you know that you didn’t somehow make it happen? How do you know that someone else didn’t “make” you do it?
Etc.

A strong mind needs no punishment, it punishes itself sufficiently.

Regardless of strength of mind, most artificial/external punishments are just salt in the wounds. Completely unnecessary.

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of MPHill MPHill (@everymorningbornfromtheashes) 2 years, 1 month ago ago

@highideals, Yeah, that helps a lot, so because right and wrong are social constructs to keep us in line we feel an adequate punishment ensues based on our experiences with law or truth or Truth, and weather or not we agree with it.

So is it safe to say with what you’ve said we as humans developed a system that punishes for what many many many individuals feel is an adequate punishment for things a person outside the scope deems acceptable? Wow. That is quite enlightening.

And if you believe in a Truth, heaven/hell that is more up to you (considering there is no physical proof of either). It could be used as a way to cope with a considerable amount of selfish gains that one feels like society shouldn’t punish for.

Thanks for your help you really took the time to figure this brain teaser out I appreciate it so much :)

[Hidden]
1
Profile photo of MPHill MPHill (@everymorningbornfromtheashes) 2 years, 1 month ago ago

@manimal, Thanks for taking your time to get to me on this perplexing issue I’ve been pondering.

“Fighting back always strengthens your mindframe, but it can weaken other parts of your mind, especially awareness and sense of truth”

Okay, I agree with that. And you say that an extreme rebellion is a stupid rebellion basically? Like, I maybe able to argue a point but am I arguing it and neglecting that I don’t believe all of it just to prove myself completely correct.

So fighting for untruths and uncertainties locks me down? That is very perceptive, because If I know it to be untrue, or I feel uncertain that what I am saying is true, I am only the only one that knows that personally. But if I keep battling it then I am just projecting a view point in it’s stereotype so to speak.

I agree constantly questioning is what keeps a strong mind, but I feel like submitting is necessary to avoid suffering when force or logic can not prevail. So I ran into that wall.

But I like what you have to say on weak minds being weak because they are weak in the first place. I do believe that… I believe it can change, with dedication.

And the reactive state is something that is punishing all in its own.

How strong does a mind have to be to be free? Is my new question for you. How is it measured? By actions or thoughts or a combination I wonder? But there are always prisons the mind can not conceive. So how strong and how perceptive must one be?
Also,
You say the mind punishes its self. It could make the best out of any situation then. What is the difference between that and submission? I think you are getting at that it is different because it will find comfort in ignorance of some kind the persons actions.

Do you think we should even have a legal system if they are unnecessary, or do you think it is good as salt in the wounds even though it is unnecessary?

I am looking for this information myself, but I appreciate you helping me sort it all out :)

[Hidden]
Reply to this topic

More Posts Like This

21

What single change would have the MOST positive impact on the world?

Could be societal, political, economical, etc. In other words, if we could only change ONE thing about the world to better our lives, what should it be?

11

Living Another Life in a Recurring Dream

Starting three weeks ago, I came back from a trip, exhausted, and slept for about 15 hours. In those 15 hours, I had a dream that spanned 17 years. The dream started with me waking up the next day and I lived out my...

1

Should "Lone Survivor's" Marcus Luttrell's dog killers be executed?

Should the men who beat and murdered Marcus Luttrell’s service dog DASY be put to death? If you have not heard of Marcus Luttrell, he is the Lone Survivor of Operation Red Wings, Afghanistan 2005. Nineteen United...

3

Whats your No. 1 book on spirituality?

We all get ideas from books and INSPIRED by them! Which is the book which inspired you the most? I know that a book cannot bring you forward, but still it can bring in the motivation needed to go forward. I start: my...

1

Hey People. I Love You

Hey People. I just hit my head kind of hard in a totally embarrassing way that involves my dog, a laptop, general clumsiness, a coffee table, and a bit of gravity. I’m going to be fine, I’ve had worse than this. Just...

1

DMT

I’m not very experienced with strong psychedelics, but I’ve been offerd some DMT by one of my best friends. (He and his dad cook DMT cacti), but I’m not sure if I should use it. Should it? Thanks

7

Suggestions for a site-wide HE 30 day challenge?

Starting in February, we’re going to have monthly 30-day challenges! We had a very successful challenge years back when the discussions were first added to HE. It’s time to revive them! Which challenge should...

1

Lesser known religions?

I used to be a very strong born-again Christian, but recently became Agnostic after God refused to communicate with me after years of pleading to him. I’m still interested in religion though, and God may or may not...

3

Without Death's Certainty

Without Death’s Certainty Without Death’s certainty, my Love, I would neither mourn, nor cherish you You would be resigned To an old page in my story Without Death’s certainty, my Love, I would neither...

1

White Bar of Light

January 23, 2015 at 4:52 am. I was having a hard time sleeping as I had a sore hip and decided to lay on the floor to stretch. I had one foot up on the wall. A solid bar of very white light appeared about 1 1/2 to 2 feet...

3

Favorite Energetic / Workout Music

What is your favorite workout music? I’m looking not only to expand my playlist but also to open up the discussion of our various sources of musical inspiration and energy. I began this post because I’m a bit...

1

I Would Like to Hear Your Suggestions..

So a little while back I created a discussion on here that was labelled, “Spaying or Neuturing”, and most of you guys were against it, including myself. Reason being? First and foremost I live by the code:...

5

The needle.

Playing off Manimal’s story; You’ve become curious. You begin to question things, and you rebel. Your parents are no longer the wisdom givers, but simple boundaries to your life. They say “Don’t...

8

Share your soundcloud (Or any original music) here

One of my friends just turned me on to soundcloud the other day and I think it is a cool way for musicians to share their music. If anybody has a soundcloud or another type of original music page that they want to share...

8

Howling in the dark

You were in the woods. It was dark. You were alone. You heard a noise. A raspy, howling sound. You wondered what it was. You heard it again. And it scared you. So you ran, and you ran, and ran… you kept running...